Re: Re[2]: center embedding of relative clauses

Ted E. Dunning (ted@hnc.com)
Tue, 12 Mar 1996 08:41:59 -0800

(*) One observation, about verbs and prepositions, for example, is that
far less often then chance to they follow themselves (VB VB; P P) in
sentences. Centre-embedded constructions are almost the only exception
to this exceedingly strong and useful local statistical regularity.

in english, that is.

in fact, it has been conjectured that english (and possibly other
languages) are "positive phenomena". this term doesn't yet have a
rigorous definition, but the gist is carried by the observation that
virtually all two word phrases occur *more* often than would be
expected by the frequencies of the words in isolation. a
generalization of this is that composite phenomena occur more often
than simpler models of the probability of the parts would indicate.

this is a very slippery concept to quantify. depending on how it is
expressed, it is probably either trivial or cosmic.

if anybody does quantify it, the should reference elbert walker,
(personal communication^2).