Re: on the meaning of 'word sense'

Robert A Amsler (amsler@bellcore.com)
Mon, 1 May 1995 14:06:43 -0400

As far as I understand the goals of lexicography, the clear intention
is that the senses be distinct. This is similar to the goals
of library classification, in which it is considered incorrect to
place a book under two different call numbers. However, dictionary definitions
are often presented in a taxonomic tree in which finer distinctions
may be made at descending levels.

Whenever I've had this problem interpreting between senses in a dictionary
I have usually found that the dictionary's text was at fault, not the
intended disjointness. I usually can resolve such problems by consulting
an unabridged dictionary in which there is sufficient space to make the
distinctions left out of the abridged versions--and where the indispensible
example sentences are given. In the absence of these details, as for
example would appear in a Pocket Dictionary, there is sometimes barely a sign
of the intended distinction.